When planning a stay in Kyoto, the choice between a traditional ryokan and an Airbnb is a common dilemma.
Both options offer unique experiences, but they cater to different tastes and travel styles. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide which might be the best fit for your Kyoto adventure.
Table of Contents
What’s a Ryokan?
A ryokan is a traditional Japanese inn that offers guests a chance to experience authentic Japanese hospitality and lifestyle.
You’ll typically sleep on futons laid out on tatami-matted floors, dine on kaiseki (seasonal multi-course meals), and relax in serene communal baths, often featuring onsen (natural hot spring) water. From the architecture and décor to the service and etiquette, every aspect of a ryokan stay is designed to reflect the spirit of omotenashi—Japan’s art of heartfelt hospitality.
Traditional Ryokan: A Step Back in Time
Pros:
- Cultural Immersion: Ryokan are steeped in tradition—from tatami-matted rooms and futon bedding to sliding shoji screens and seasonal kaiseki meals. Staying at a ryokan is like stepping into a living museum of Japanese hospitality (omotenashi).
- Onsen Experience: Many ryokan include access to onsen (natural hot springs), which provide a rejuvenating and authentic Japanese relaxation experience.
- Personal Service: With attentive, personalized service, ryokan offer a warm, intimate atmosphere that can make you feel truly cared for.
Cons:
- Higher Cost: Traditional ryokan tend to be more expensive than many Airbnb options, especially if you opt for full-course kaiseki meals.
- Limited Flexibility: Ryokan stays are usually structured with set meal times and strict etiquette, which might feel too rigid if you prefer a more casual, independent schedule.
- Language Barriers: Although many ryokan are making efforts to accommodate international guests, language differences can sometimes pose a challenge.
Airbnb: Modern Comfort with a Local Touch
Pros:
- Flexibility and Privacy: Airbnb accommodations often offer more privacy and the flexibility to set your own schedule. You can cook your own meals, host gatherings, or simply enjoy the space at your leisure.
- Variety: From modern apartments in bustling neighborhoods to traditional machiya (townhouses) with a historical flair, Airbnb provides a wide range of options to suit your style and budget.
- Local Experience: Staying in an Airbnb can offer a more “local” perspective—neighbors might share insider tips about hidden gems and local hangouts that aren’t on the typical tourist map.
Cons:
- Variable Quality: The quality of Airbnb accommodations can vary widely, so it’s important to read reviews and do thorough research before booking.
- Less Cultural Experience: While some Airbnb hosts embrace traditional decor, most properties lack the immersive cultural elements—like onsen baths and kaiseki dining—that a ryokan offers.
- Self-Service: With Airbnb, you’re generally on your own, which means no daily cleaning or on-demand concierge service that a ryokan provides.
Which Should You Choose?
- For a Deep Cultural Experience:
If you’re looking to fully immerse yourself in Japanese traditions, enjoy a meticulously curated kaiseki meal, and experience the art of omotenashi, a ryokan is the way to go. It’s perfect for first-time visitors who want to experience the “old Japan” firsthand.
- For Flexibility and Modern Living:
If you prefer the comfort and privacy of a modern home with the freedom to set your own pace, an Airbnb might be more suitable. This option is especially great if you plan to explore Kyoto extensively, prefer cooking your own meals, or are traveling with a group or family.
Top 3 Ryokans in Kyoto
With a history spanning over 300 years, Tawaraya is renowned as one of Kyoto’s finest ryokans. Guests can experience unparalleled personalized service, traditional Japanese architecture, and serene private gardens. Its central location provides easy access to Kyoto’s cultural landmarks.
Nestled along the tranquil Hozu River in the scenic Arashiyama district, Hoshinoya Kyoto offers a secluded retreat accessible via a private boat ride. The ryokan combines traditional Japanese design with modern luxury, featuring exquisite kaiseki cuisine and rooms overlooking the river.
Established in 1818, Hiiragiya Ryokan has been operated by the same family for six generations. Located in downtown Kyoto, it offers a harmonious blend of historic charm and modern comforts, with rooms showcasing traditional craftsmanship and views of beautiful gardens.
The Kyoto Experience: More Than Just Sightseeing
Ultimately, the best choice depends on your travel style, budget, and what you want to get out of your Kyoto experience. Consider mixing it up: perhaps a few nights in a traditional ryokan to soak in the culture, followed by a stay in an Airbnb for a more laid-back, modern vibe.
Ready to plan your Kyoto stay? Whichever option you choose, you’re sure to create unforgettable memories in this enchanting city. Happy travels!
To maximize your Kyoto Journey, join our free walking tour to deeply immerse yourself in the Kyoto experience with a local English-speaking guide!
FAQ Section
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: Are ryokan suitable for first-time visitors to Japan?
A: Absolutely. If you want an immersive cultural experience, a ryokan is one of the best ways to understand Japanese tradition and hospitality firsthand.
Q2: Can I book a ryokan if I don’t speak Japanese?
A: Yes, many ryokan in Kyoto now cater to international travelers, with English-speaking staff, translated guides, and simplified etiquette instructions.
Q3: Are there budget-friendly ryokan options in Kyoto?
A: While many ryokan are high-end, Kyoto also has more affordable options with fewer amenities that still offer a warm, authentic experience.
Q4: Do Airbnbs in Kyoto offer traditional features like tatami rooms?
A: Some do! You can find Airbnb listings in Kyoto that preserve traditional elements like tatami flooring, sliding shoji doors, or even small inner gardens.
Q5: Is it okay to stay in both an Airbnb and a ryokan during my trip?
A: Definitely. Many travelers combine a few nights at a ryokan for cultural immersion with an Airbnb stay for flexibility and budget balance.
Q6: Are meals always included at a ryokan?
A: Not always. Some ryokan offer meal packages, while others let you choose. Kaiseki dinners and Japanese breakfasts are highly recommended for the full experience.
Q7: Are Airbnbs in Kyoto legally operated?
A: Most are, but it’s wise to double-check that your Airbnb is registered with a license number (as required by Japanese law) to avoid any issues.
Q8: Will I share a bathroom at a ryokan?
A: It depends. Higher-end ryokan often have private baths in guest rooms, while others may have shared baths, including public-style onsen.
Q9: What kind of service can I expect at a ryokan?
A: Service is deeply personalized—staff may greet you with tea, help you with your yukata (casual kimono), and guide you through the meal or bath etiquette.
Q10: Which is better for long stays—Airbnb or ryokan?
A: Airbnb is generally more practical for longer stays, especially if you want to cook your own meals, do laundry, or have more privacy and independence.
